Illustration of a person holding a large magnifying glass over a small shopfront, showing a tidy door, window and path inside the lens.

What Does Google Want From Your Website? Its Own Answer in 5 Points

Google publishes what it looks for in a website. Here are its five main points in its own words, and a quick check for each one you can run this month.

You've added keywords. You set up a Google Business Profile. You have a few good reviews.

And the plumber across town still shows up first.

So what does Google actually want from your site? You don't have to guess. Google publishes it, in plain language, in its own documentation. This post puts those pages side by side and turns them into checks you can run this month.

The quick answer

Google's own guidance boils down to five things:

  1. Google can reach and read your pages. No blocks, no errors, real text on the page.
  2. Your pages help people. Written for customers first, not for search engines.
  3. Your site works well on a phone. Google ranks the mobile version of your site.
  4. You don't use shortcuts Google calls spam. Keyword stuffing, fake reviews, bought links.
  5. For local searches, your Business Profile is complete and well known. Relevance, distance and prominence.

Everything below is detail on those five, with Google's own words and where to check each one.

1. Google can reach and read your pages

Google's Search Essentials start with three technical requirements:

  • Googlebot (Google's crawler) isn't blocked.
  • The page works, meaning it loads without an error.
  • The page has indexable content: real text Google can read, not just images or a page that's empty until a script runs.

Most small business sites pass. When one doesn't, it's usually a setting left over from a website build, like a "discourage search engines" box still ticked.

How to check: add your site to Google Search Console (free), paste your homepage and main service pages into the URL Inspection tool at the top, and look for "URL is on Google".

2. Your pages help people

This is the big one. Google's guide to creating helpful content asks three questions about every page:

  • Who made it? Make it clear who's behind the page, with a name and an About page where people would expect one.
  • How was it made? If you used AI or automation, would a reader want to know?
  • Why was it made? Google calls this "perhaps the most important question". The page should exist mainly to help people, not mainly to attract search visits.

You'll see E-E-A-T mentioned a lot: experience, expertise, authoritativeness and trustworthiness. Google says plainly that "E-E-A-T itself isn't a specific ranking factor," and that trust matters most of the four. It's a way to think about quality, not a box to tick.

For a service business, "helpful" is very practical:

  • One page per main service, saying what you do, where, for whom and what happens next.
  • The questions customers ask on the phone, answered on the page.
  • Real photos of your work and your team, real names, a real address or service area.
  • Prices, hours and contact details that match what you'd say if someone called.

Google's own best practices add one more: use the words people would actually search for, in prominent places like the page title and headings. "Water heater repair in Tulsa" beats "comprehensive plumbing solutions."

3. Your site works well on a phone

Google is direct about this: it "uses the mobile version of a site's content, crawled with the smartphone agent, for indexing and ranking" (mobile-first indexing). If something is on your desktop site but hidden or missing on mobile, assume Google doesn't see it.

Speed is part of the picture, with a limit. Google's page experience page says "Core Web Vitals are used by our ranking systems" (those are Google's measures of loading speed, responsiveness and layout jumping around). The same page says good scores don't guarantee your pages will rank at the top. A slow site can hold you back. A fast site alone won't carry you.

The same page also lists secure pages (HTTPS, the padlock in the browser) and avoiding pop-ups that cover the content.

How to check: open your site on your own phone and try to call you, find your hours and book. Then run your homepage through PageSpeed Insights (free) and look at the mobile tab.

4. You don't use shortcuts Google calls spam

Google's spam policies are the other half of Search Essentials. The ones small businesses run into most:

  • Keyword stuffing, like a footer listing 40 towns.
  • Buying links, or swapping links just to rank.
  • Lots of thin pages that only change the town name.
  • Content copied from other sites.

Breaking these can push a page down or remove it from results entirely. The myths that lead people here are covered in 7 SEO myths still costing small businesses clicks.

5. For local searches: relevance, distance, prominence

When someone searches "electrician near me", the map results work a little differently. Google's Business Profile help says local results are based mainly on three things:

  • Relevance: how well your profile matches the search. Complete, detailed information helps.
  • Distance: how far you are from the searcher. You can't change this one.
  • Prominence: how well known your business is. Google names links from other websites, and your review count and ratings.

Google also says "Businesses with complete and accurate info are more likely to show up in local search results," and that there's no way to pay for a better local ranking.

How to check: search your own business name on your phone and read your profile as a customer would. Is the category right? Are the hours right this week? Are your services listed? Are there reviews from the last few months, with replies?

Why your competitor might still be ahead

Google compares you with the other businesses showing up for the same search, not with the whole internet. So the bar is set locally. If the shop across town has a page for each service, a complete profile with steady reviews, and a site that loads well on a phone, that's what you're up against.

The side-by-side comparison is in why does my competitor rank higher than me?

A monthly routine you can actually keep

Thirty minutes, once a month:

  • Search Console: check the Pages report for new errors, and see which searches bring people in.
  • Business Profile: confirm hours (especially around holidays), add a few photos of recent work, reply to new reviews.
  • One page: improve one service page. Answer a question a customer asked this month.
  • Phone test: open the site on your phone and tap through the call and booking buttons.

That's not a trick. It's simply doing, steadily, what Google says it rewards.

When to call someone

  • URL Inspection says your main pages aren't on Google, and you can't see why.
  • Search Console shows a manual action, or traffic dropped sharply and stayed down.
  • Your site fails on mobile and your web person isn't around to fix it.

If you'd like a second pair of eyes, talk to us.

No comments yet

Managed Nerds Weekly

Get the week's posts in one email

New IT, security and SEO posts every Monday. That's it.