Illustration of a person pinning blank page cards to a wall board divided into three sections and linked with string.

Keyword Strategy for a Small Business: A 90-Day Plan

A keyword list isn't a strategy. Here's how to give every page one job, fix the pages you have first, and fill the gaps over three months, with a simple map to track it.

You have a site. You have a handful of blog posts. You've picked some keywords.

And you still can't say which page is supposed to do what.

That's what I'd call a keyword list with no strategy. It costs you the same thing every time: you write the wrong next post, you fix the wrong page first, and three months later you can't tell if anything worked.

If you still need to work out which phrases are worth chasing, start with What Keywords Should My Business Target?. This post starts after that. You have a list. Now it needs an order.

The quick answer

  1. Make a keyword map: one row per page, with the main phrase that page is for.
  2. Month 1: see what you already show up for in Search Console, and fill in the map.
  3. Month 2: fix the pages that already exist. Titles, headings, first paragraphs.
  4. Month 3: write new pages only for the gaps the map shows.
  5. Review monthly, for 20 minutes, and change one thing at a time.
  6. Cut phrases that bring visitors but never calls.

What a strategy adds to a list

A list says what you want. A strategy says what you do first.

It answers three questions:

  • Which page is this phrase for? If the answer is "none," that's a gap. If it's "two," that's a conflict.
  • What does the searcher want? To hire you, to compare, or to learn. A learner and a buyer need different pages.
  • What are we doing about it this month? Fix a page, write a page, or leave it.

Without those answers you're guessing, just with a spreadsheet.

The keyword map

Make a sheet with these columns:

Page URL, Main phrase, Also covers, What the searcher wants, Status, Next action, Review date.

"Status" has three values: fine, fix, new page needed.

Don't copy the sheet from the earlier post. It's a different job. That sheet is a list of phrases. This one is a list of pages, and the phrases hang off them.

Month 1: see where you stand

Open the Performance report in Google Search Console. It shows clicks, impressions, click-through rate and average position, and the Queries and Pages tabs show them by search and by address. The default view covers the last three months.

For each page on your site:

  1. Click the page in the Pages tab.
  2. Switch to Queries.
  3. Write the top searches in the "Also covers" column.
  4. Pick the one phrase the page is really for and put it in "Main phrase."

Then look at what you've got.

  • A page whose top searches match its purpose: status fine.
  • A page that shows up for the wrong things, or has impressions and few clicks: status fix.
  • A phrase on your list with no page at all: add a row, status new page needed.

Also look for the conflict. If two of your pages show up for the same search, readers and Google both have to guess which is the answer. Google's page on consolidating duplicate URLs says redirects and canonical tags are strong signals for which one should win. Often the simplest fix is to merge them.

Month 2: fix what exists

This is where the quick wins usually are, because Google already knows these pages.

For each page marked fix:

  • Title. Google's SEO Starter Guide says a good title is "unique to the page, clear and concise, and accurately describes the contents of the page." Put the main phrase in it, in words a person would say.
  • Main heading. It should say the same thing as the title.
  • First paragraph. Answer the question. Don't warm up.
  • The rest of the page. Does it cover what the searcher wanted? If someone searching "how long does a home inspection take" lands on a page that never says how long, that's the fix.
  • Links. Link from your related posts to this page, with link text that says what's there. The Starter Guide notes that link text "tells users and Google something about the page you're linking to."

Don't repeat the phrase over and over. Google's spam policies define keyword stuffing as filling a page with keywords "in an attempt to manipulate rankings."

Website Not Getting Clicks From Google? Check Your Title Tags First goes deeper on titles.

Month 3: fill the gaps

Now look at the rows marked new page needed. Not all of them deserve a page.

A quick check on each one:

  1. Search it yourself in a private browser window. What comes up? Directories, service pages, blog posts, videos? That's what Google thinks people want for that phrase.
  2. Match the type. If every result is a service page, a blog post probably won't compete. If every result is a how-to, a service page won't either.
  3. Ask whether you can say something the results don't. Your process, your local detail, the thing customers ask on the phone.

If the answer to the third is no, skip it for now. A thin page is worse than a gap.

Google's guidance on helpful content asks whether a page "clearly demonstrate[s] first-hand expertise and a depth of knowledge." That's the bar for the new ones.

The monthly review

Twenty minutes. Same time every month.

  1. Open the map.
  2. Check Search Console for each page you changed last month.
  3. Mark each one: better, same, worse.
  4. Pick one or two next actions. Not ten.

Give changes time. The Starter Guide says some changes take effect within hours and others take several months, and it recommends waiting a few weeks before judging. So don't change the same page every week.

And change one thing at a time where you can. If you rewrite the title, the heading and the whole body at once, you won't know which one did it.

Know when to drop a keyword

Some phrases bring visitors who never call.

Look at your leads, not just your traffic. If a phrase has plenty of clicks and not one phone call or form in three months, it's the wrong phrase. Don't build more pages around it. Move the effort to a phrase that sounds more like someone about to hire you.

What this won't do

It won't promise a ranking. Nobody outside Google can, and the people who do are selling something. A map just means that every page has a job, every month has a task, and you can tell afterward what happened.

When to get help

  • You have a lot of pages and the map is bigger than you have time for.
  • Two pages keep competing for the same search and you're not sure which to keep.
  • Visitors go up but calls don't, and you can't see why.

Building and maintaining the map is the core of our SEO and marketing service. If you'd rather talk it through first, get in touch.

Related reading

No comments yet

Managed Nerds Weekly

Get the week's posts in one email

New IT, security and SEO posts every Monday. That's it.