You pay for SEO every month. You get a report every month.
The phone isn't ringing any more than it used to.
Sooner or later you ask the uncomfortable question: is anyone actually doing anything?
SEO takes time. So does busywork. The difference is that real SEO leaves evidence: changes to your website, movement in your own Google data, and a plan you can read. Busywork leaves PDFs.
The quick answer
- Make sure you own your Google Search Console property. The agency should be a user on it, not the owner.
- Ask for a list of changes made to your website in the last three months.
- Compare their report to Search Console yourself. Clicks, impressions and the pages gaining ground.
- Ask how leads are tracked. Calls and form fills, not just rankings.
- Ask for next month's plan in writing. Which pages, which fixes, why.
If they can't produce those, you've found the problem.
Red flag 1: you don't control your own data
Google Search Console is Google's free tool that shows how your site does in search. It belongs to you, not your agency.
Google's Search Console permissions page says owners have full control of a property, and only owners can add and remove users. Everyone else is a full or restricted user.
A healthy setup looks like this:
- You (the business) are a verified owner.
- The agency is added as a user.
- If you cancel, your data and history stay with you.
To check, open Search Console, pick your site and go to Settings > Users and permissions. Only owners can see that page. If you can't open it, you're not an owner.
One more thing from that same Google page: removing someone as an owner doesn't delete their verification token, so they can verify again and get back in. If you part ways with an agency, delete their unused tokens too (they're listed on the Users and permissions page).
The same goes for your Google Analytics, your Google Business Profile, your domain and your website login. They should be in your name, with the agency added to them.
If an agency won't hand over access to your own accounts, that tells you plenty.
Red flag 2: the report talks rankings, not results
Rankings can be useful. They aren't what pays your bills.
A useful monthly report answers five things:
- What changed on the site
- Why it matters
- What improved
- What's planned next
- How it connects to calls, form fills or bookings
If the report is twelve pages of screenshots and you still can't answer "did we get more calls?", it's not doing its job.
Red flag 3: nothing ever changes on your website
SEO is changes, not monitoring.
Google's SEO Starter Guide is about helping search engines find, crawl and understand your pages. That means work on the site itself. If months go by without any of these, ask what's happening:
- Technical problems fixed
- Service pages written or improved
- Content updated or added
- Internal links cleaned up
- Call and form tracking set up and tested
Google's own advice on hiring an SEO suggests asking "Will you share with me all the changes you make to my site". Ask it.
The monthly proof list to request
Ask for this every month. Copy it into an email if you like.
From Search Console:
- Clicks and impressions, compared to last month and the same month last year
- Searches that are gaining ground
- Pages that are gaining visibility
Work done:
- Pages updated or added, with links
- Technical issues fixed
- Anything removed, and why
Lead tracking:
- Phone clicks tracked
- Form submissions tracked
- Quote or booking requests tracked
Next month:
- Which pages are being improved
- What content is being written
- Which technical items are next
If the answer is "SEO is complicated", that's not an answer.
"SEO takes time" can be true, or it can be a shield
It's true that SEO is slow. Google's Starter Guide says some changes show up in a few hours and others could take several months, and suggests waiting a few weeks before judging a change.
But slow isn't the same as invisible. Even early on, you should see signs of work:
- Pages getting indexed properly
- Technical errors going down in Search Console
- Service pages expanded and improved
- Impressions starting to rise
- Your Business Profile filled out and active
If it's month six and the only update is "we built backlinks", with no list, no explanation of quality and no plan, you're probably paying for busywork. (Bought links are their own problem: Someone Offered 500 Backlinks for $99 covers why.)
Busywork that sounds like SEO
These often produce little on their own:
- Endless directory submissions with no plan behind them
- AI-written blog posts that have nothing to do with your services or your area
- Reports full of numbers with no actions attached
- Taking credit for seasonal busy months
- Blaming "algorithm updates" every time results dip
A real partner tells you what happened, what they're changing and why.
Watch out for guarantees
Google is blunt about this: "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google." The same page says to be wary of anyone who claims a special relationship with Google, offers a "priority submit", or won't clearly explain what they intend to do.
If an agency promised guaranteed rankings or instant results, that's worth remembering when you read their reports.
What a good SEO relationship looks like
Boring, in a good way:
- You own your accounts.
- You can see your data any time.
- The work done is listed and visible.
- Priorities are clear.
- Reports connect to leads.
And they can say, in plain English: "Here's what we did, here's what it changed, and here's what's next."
If you think you've been paying for busywork
Don't argue. Audit.
- Get owner access to Search Console, Analytics, your Business Profile and your domain.
- Ask for the proof list above for the last three months.
- Look at clicks and impressions in Search Console yourself, over the longest date range it offers.
- If the work isn't there, give notice, and remove their access and verification tokens when you leave.
If a past agency did more harm than good, How Do I Fix Bad SEO from a Previous Agency? covers the cleanup.
When to get help
- You've paid for SEO for six months or more and can't point to a single change on your site.
- You don't have owner access to your own Google accounts and can't get it.
- Your Search Console shows a drop nobody has explained.
If you'd like a second opinion on what's been done and what's missing, talk to us. You can also see how our SEO service reports on the work every month.






No comments yet