Illustration of a person sorting old pages into four piles on a table, with a bin and a signpost arrow beside them.

Old Blog Posts: Update, Merge or Delete? How to Decide for Each One

Old posts with wrong prices, dead links or the same answer three times? Here's a four-pile sheet to decide which to update, merge, redirect or remove, and what to do with the address.

You wrote a post two years ago. It still gets a few visits a month.

It also still says your old phone number, recommends a tool that doesn't exist anymore, and quotes a price from before the supplier changed it.

That's the cost of an old post. It's not that Google "punishes" it. It's that a customer reads it, believes it, and acts on it.

This post is about the decision most people skip: what to do with each old post. Not every one should be updated.

If you already know a page is worth fixing and want a method for rewriting it, How to Use AI to Update Old Blog Posts and Pages for SEO covers that. This one is about deciding which posts get that effort, and which get merged or removed.

The quick answer

  1. List every post with its address, publish date and clicks from the last few months.
  2. Sort each one into one of four piles: leave, update, merge or remove.
  3. Update posts that still have a purpose but have gone stale.
  4. Merge posts that answer the same question, and redirect the old address to the one you keep.
  5. Remove posts with no purpose left. Redirect to a real replacement if there is one. If there isn't, let the address return a plain "not found."
  6. Only change the date on a page you really changed.

Step 1: Make the list

A spreadsheet. One row per post. Columns:

URL, Published, Clicks (last 3 months), Still true?, Decision, Redirect to, Done on.

Get the clicks from the Performance report in Google Search Console. The Pages tab groups results by address, and the default view covers the past three months.

"Still true?" is your own call. Read the post. Check the phone number, the prices, the product names, the laws, the links. This is the slow column, and it's the one that matters.

Step 2: Sort into four piles

Leave it alone

Evergreen posts that are still correct. "How to read a roofing estimate" doesn't age much.

Google's SEO Starter Guide says to check in on previously published content and update it as needed. Checking is the job. If it's fine, you're done.

Update it

The post has a purpose, and some of it is out of date. Typical signs:

  • It mentions a year, a version, a price or a law that has changed.
  • Links on it go nowhere.
  • It answers a question the way people asked it three years ago.
  • It gets impressions in Search Console but few clicks.

One thing to know about freshness. Google's ranking systems guide describes freshness systems that show newer content "for queries where it would be expected," like a new film or a recent earthquake. A post on "best accounting software" is that kind of query. A post on "how to read a roofing estimate" mostly isn't. So spend your update time on the first kind.

Merge it

You wrote three posts about the same thing over four years. Each one is a little different. None is the best answer.

Pick the strongest. Move anything useful from the others into it. Then redirect the old addresses to it with a permanent (301) redirect. Google's page on consolidating duplicate URLs calls a redirect "a strong signal that the target of the redirect should become canonical," and says to use it when you're deprecating a duplicate page. It also lists "to consolidate signals for similar or duplicate pages" as a reason to bother at all.

Your website platform almost certainly has a redirects setting, or a plugin that adds one. If you're not sure where it is, that's a ten-minute job for whoever built your site.

Remove it

Some posts have no purpose left: an announcement for an event that's over, a promo for a service you stopped offering, a post about a tool that shut down.

Two choices for the address:

  • A close replacement exists. Redirect it there with a 301. Google's redirect guide lists "you removed a page and you want to send users to a new page" as a use for one.
  • Nothing replaces it. Let it return a plain "not found" page. Google's documentation on HTTP status codes says 4xx errors, except 429, are treated the same, and previously indexed addresses drop out of the index.

What not to do is point every dead post at your home page. The reader wanted a specific answer. Dropping them on the home page isn't one. Send them to something that actually replaces what they were looking for, or don't send them anywhere.

Step 3: About the date

When you update a post, show it. Google's guidance on publication dates says to put a visible date on the page, to label it "Publish" or "Last updated," and to keep dates consistent.

Do it honestly. Google's helpful content questions include: "Are you changing the date of pages to make them seem fresh when the content has not substantially changed?"

Fixing a typo isn't an update. New prices, a rewritten section and rechecked links are.

A line that works at the bottom of the post: "Originally published March 2024. Updated October 2026."

Step 4: Check it afterward

Give it a few weeks. The Starter Guide says some changes take effect in hours and others take months, and suggests waiting a few weeks before judging.

Then go back to Search Console, open the page in the Performance report, and compare the weeks before with the weeks after. Clicks matter. Calls and form fills matter more.

Don't expect a jump in a few days. Anyone who promises one is guessing. Nobody outside Google can tell you how fast a page will move, or whether it will.

Keeping it from piling up again

  • Date the things that expire. Prices, offers and "this year" posts get a calendar reminder.
  • One owner for the sheet. Someone checks it twice a year.
  • Don't publish what you won't maintain. A post that quotes a price is a post you've agreed to keep current.
  • When you change a URL, add the redirect the same day. Not "later."

How often a whole site needs attention is a different question, and How Often Should You Update Your Website for SEO? answers it.

When to get help

  • You have a hundred posts and no idea which ones earn their keep.
  • You merged or removed posts and now see "not found" errors in Search Console that you can't explain.
  • Your website platform doesn't have an obvious way to add redirects.

This kind of cleanup is part of our SEO and marketing service. If you'd like to talk it through first, get in touch.

Related reading

No comments yet

Managed Nerds Weekly

Get the week's posts in one email

New IT, security and SEO posts every Monday. That's it.