Retro screen-print illustration: a man sneaks through a glass-windowed tunnel arching over a city while watchers with binoculars at both ends still see where he goes in and comes out.

Does a VPN Make You Private? What It Hides and What It Doesn't

A VPN or Incognito window doesn't make you invisible online. Here's exactly who can still see what, the free privacy fixes that work without a VPN, and how to choose one if you need it.

You switched on a VPN, or opened an Incognito window, and figured nobody could see what you were doing online.

Here's the deal: a VPN doesn't make you private. It changes who can see your traffic. Your internet provider and the coffee shop Wi-Fi see less, the VPN company sees more, and the websites and ad trackers you visit can usually still recognize you. Incognito mode does even less than that.

That doesn't make a VPN useless. It means you should know what you're paying for.

The quick answer

  1. A VPN hides which sites you visit from your internet provider and the local Wi-Fi. It hands that view to the VPN company instead.
  2. It doesn't hide you from websites you sign into, or from cookies and browser fingerprinting.
  3. Incognito only stops your own device keeping a history. Websites, your employer and your internet provider can still see your activity (Google Chrome Help).
  4. Most of the privacy wins are free: check for the lock icon, turn on secure DNS, block third-party cookies, and sign out of accounts you aren't using.
  5. On a work laptop, don't add a personal VPN. Use the company's own remote access.

Who can see what

Most of the confusion comes from treating "private" as one thing. It's really a list of different people who could be watching, and a VPN only changes some of them.

A quick explainer first. HTTPS is the lock icon in your address bar: it scrambles what you send to a site and what it sends back. DNS is the internet's phone book: your device asks it for a site's address before connecting, and that question can travel unencrypted.

Here's what each party can typically see when the site uses HTTPS.

Who's looking

Without a VPN

With a VPN

Public Wi-Fi or your internet provider

Which sites you visit, not the pages or what you type

That you're using a VPN and how much data, not which sites

The VPN company

Nothing

What your internet provider used to see

Websites you visit

Your real IP address (your rough location)

The VPN's IP address instead

Accounts you're signed into

Who you are

Still who you are

Ad trackers (cookies, fingerprinting)

Can follow you across sites

Can still follow you across sites

Your employer, on a work device

Whatever its security tools record

The same; those tools run on the laptop itself

The FTC puts the middle row plainly: a VPN mostly hides your traffic from your internet provider or the Wi-Fi network, but it doesn't make you anonymous; it shifts your trust to the VPN company (FTC: Shopping for a VPN app?). The EFF's guide makes the same point and is skeptical of how VPNs are marketed (EFF Surveillance Self-Defense: Choosing the VPN That's Right for You).

So the honest question isn't "am I private?" It's "who do I trust more with my browsing: my internet provider or this VPN company?"

What Incognito mode actually does

Investigator looking through files on a computer to discover what you did online

Incognito keeps your history off your own computer. That's the whole job.

Google's own help page is clear about it. Incognito doesn't save your history, cookies or site data once you close every Incognito window, but it "doesn't make you invisible." Websites, Google included, and whoever runs your network (your employer, your school, your internet provider) may still see what you do (Google Chrome Help).

Good for: shopping for a gift on a shared computer. Not good for: hiding anything from anyone but the next person at the keyboard.

Google learned the hard way that people expected more. To settle a class action over Incognito tracking, in April 2024 Google agreed to delete or de-identify Incognito browsing records it had collected and to change how it describes the mode (CNBC).

The free fixes, easiest first

None of these need a VPN.

1. Check for the lock

Before you type a password or card number, look for the lock icon or https:// in the address bar. The FTC notes that most websites now encrypt traffic this way, which is what makes public Wi-Fi far safer than it used to be (FTC: Are Public Wi-Fi Networks Safe?). No lock, no login.

2. Turn on secure DNS

Secure DNS encrypts that phone-book lookup, so the network can't read the list of sites you look up.

In Chrome on a computer: More (three dots) > Settings > Privacy and security > Security, then under Advanced, turn on Use secure DNS (Google Chrome Help). Chrome turns it on in automatic mode by default, so check it hasn't been switched off. On a company-managed device you may not be able to change it, and that's fine; IT controls DNS there.

In Microsoft Edge, type secure DNS into the search box at the top of Settings to find the same switch.

3. Block third-party cookies

Third-party cookies are set by companies other than the site you're on, usually ad networks, and they're how one company follows you from site to site.

In Chrome: More > Settings > Privacy and security > Third-party cookies, then choose Block third-party cookies (Google Chrome Help). If a site you need breaks, add it to the exceptions list on that same page instead of turning blocking off everywhere.

Browser cookies stored inside a browser, rendered as a digital cookie jar

Cookies remember your cart. Third-party cookies remember you, everywhere.

4. Sign out, or separate your profiles

If you're signed into Google, Facebook or Microsoft in the same browser, those accounts know it's you, VPN or not. Use a separate browser profile for personal browsing and one for work. It's the cheapest privacy tool there is.

5. See what your browser gives away

Trackers can also identify a browser by its "fingerprint": the mix of screen size, fonts, settings and extensions that makes your setup unusual. A VPN changes your IP address; it doesn't change any of that. The EFF's free Cover Your Tracks test shows how unique your browser looks and whether it blocks trackers.

If you do use a VPN

A VPN is worth having when you're on a network you don't trust (a hotel, an airport, a conference), when you don't want your home internet provider building a profile of your browsing, or when you're traveling.

Pick it like you'd pick anyone who can see your traffic:

  • Read the privacy policy before you install. The FTC warns that researchers found some VPN apps didn't encrypt traffic at all, asked for permissions they didn't need, or shared data with third parties for marketing (FTC).
  • Be suspicious of free. Running a VPN costs money. If you're not paying, ask how they are.
  • Look for an independent audit of the provider's no-logging claims, published on its own site.
  • Turn on the kill switch if the app has one, so your traffic doesn't quietly fall back to your normal connection when the VPN drops.
  • Don't treat it as antivirus. A VPN doesn't stop malware, phishing or a bad download. That's a different job.

One more data point, so you can weigh it. CISA's December 2024 mobile security guidance, written for people at high risk of being targeted by state hackers, goes as far as advising against personal VPNs, because they mostly move the risk from your internet provider to the VPN company (CISA: Mobile Communications Best Practice Guidance). Most of us aren't in that group, but the reasoning is the same: you're choosing who to trust.

Person using a VPN to access the internet

A VPN is a tunnel to someone else's network. Choose the someone carefully.

Why internet providers are in the picture at all

Your internet provider handles every connection you make. Encryption hides what's inside, but the provider can still see where you're connecting.

What do they do with it? An FTC staff report on six major U.S. internet providers found some combined customers' personal information with browsing data for advertising, collected and used more data than customers would expect, and offered disclosures and opt-outs that were often inadequate (FTC staff report, October 2021). It's worth looking through your own provider's account privacy settings for an advertising opt-out.

On a work laptop

If your business gives you a laptop, don't install a personal VPN on it.

  • It can trip security alerts. A sudden connection to an unknown VPN service looks a lot like something an attacker would set up, and someone may have to investigate it.
  • It may break company policy on how you connect to work systems.
  • It doesn't hide anything from the company anyway. Security tools on the device see what happens on the device.

If you need to reach work systems from home or on the road, use the remote access your IT provider set up. On Windows 11, a company VPN usually lives under Settings > Network & internet > VPN, or in a separate app your IT team installed.

Staff rule: "Work laptop, work connection. No personal VPNs or browser VPN extensions."

When to get help

  • You need staff to reach company files securely from home or while traveling, and right now they're using a personal VPN or nothing.
  • Someone installed a VPN or "privacy" extension on a work device and you don't know what it is.
  • You've had a customer or insurer ask how remote access is secured and you don't have an answer.

These are setup questions, and they're quicker to fix than to explain after an incident. If you'd like a second opinion, we can help.

Related reading

No comments yet

Managed Nerds Weekly

Get the week's posts in one email

New IT, security and SEO posts every Monday. That's it.